Yes I’m sure that I’m not on a free member tier of all these creators. There used to be a “follow” option for creators.
Edit: I just looked in the app. Apparently the website is not updated or something because when I go to memberships on the website I only see the two creators I actually pay something every month and no one else. In the app I can see every creator I “followed” in the past which got turned into a “free member” or something. But that doesn’t show on the website only in the app.
I figured it out now and added the solution to the post in case other people were wondering the same thing.